X

Truth is in a man's actions, not in someone else's blind accusations.

Click for the video
X
November 29 2020

Do I continue to deal with the Childrens Aid Society or ask them to leave next time they show up?
Theresa Kuhn audience: Public
Chris Carter, I have studied an incredible amount of material in the past year and it r...
ON Sault Ste Marie Algoma Society Mission Statement
Algoma CAS Sault Ste Marie Ontario Canada audience: Public
We are one of 47 Children's Aid Societies in Ontario. Each Society is an independent, n...
Happy Birthday Carmela 22 January 2015 Alienated father birthday wishes
Charlie Mercieca audience: Authenticated Login and access Happy Birthday Carmela 22 January 2015 Alienated father birthday wishes
Happy Birthday to you, my little button, Carmela! You're 11 today. I wish you the beste...
Calling the FRO on behalf of my dad to have this financial abuse stopped
David McDonough audience: Public
We have a system that targets people based on how much pain and suffering they can caus...
Navigation

Authors & content contributions
Categories
Groups
Member Login
Page Grid

FOLLOW Brainsyntax VIA EMAIL Enter your email address and receive notifications of selective new pages by email.

Join 12050 other brainsyntax email notification followers

Searching for my children

Fathers in distress if you ever need to talk, or just vent, please message us Contact: Fathers Rights Canada
Deadly Epidemic Against Dads


Parents

To my children & To those that may be concerned ...
Advocacy Canada
Re: Lawyer wanted Sudbury Ontario Family Law - Alienated Father
Amanda Brake
audience: Public

Call george <a href="../PinWall?page=1&amp;page_limit=25&amp;q=Florentis" target="_blan...
Chris York Sudbury Ontario love for the LGTB community
Bobbie Sasha Lisa C Shears Kendall
audience: Authenticated Login and access Chris York Sudbury Ontario love for the LGTB community

Countdown is on... 1 hour until the season premier of The Last Ship. Disturb at your ow...
Father Rights Canada / I found out 2 days later she’s with someone who is an ex con

audience: Authenticated Login and access Father Rights Canada / I found out 2 days later she’s with someone who is an ex con

I’m in need of advice my x just left me this past Monday and I found out 2 days later she’...
Parents lawsuits against CAS often is dismissed at a Summary Judgment Motion
Bill Korbak
audience: Public

CAS Lawsuit Primer 101 After being victimized by the CAS, many parents want to sue the ...
Abusive fathers
Valerie Kirwan
audience: Public

It's quite obvious that you have not read in depth what the Fathers 4 Justice Site is a...
Children's Aid Algoma destroyed 1000's of families and children Sault Sainte Marie
Elli T.
audience: Public

this has to gone to far!!! This is very sick!! ...
Re: Father Rights Canada /mother makes all the decisions for our child without me
Tina R. Carriere
audience: Public

From helping my son with his parenting time, court, lawyers etc, you have very little. Sad...
Re Father Rights Canada / My heart goes out to you all
Diane Rand Loewen
audience: Public

The fact that you had to lose everything makes me sick! I&rsquo;m witnessing first hand...
New Video Link Smiths Falls Ontario Police and Family Children Services violating our rights CAS Ontario
Derek James
audience: Public

Our Youtube copies of CAS were taken down but we had a back up plan. The CAS (a communi...
Re: Father Rights Canada terrified that she has legal representation and he does not
Jeanne Lauck
audience: Public

Whatever he does ....do not breach that EPO....the cops are waiting with baited breath!! ...
brainsyntax.com

★★★ Join brainsyntax

Log On as Member

X

Albert Fraser calls hair testing developing science warns against it in child protection cases

Tuesday, March 8, 2016 - Information - Karissa Donkin - Bob Murphy

A retired forensic toxicologist is calling on Nova Scotia to stop using hair-based drug and alcohol testing, arguing it is a "developing science" that shouldn't be used in child protection cases until more is known.

"It's an emerging discipline," said Albert Fraser, who worked at the Victoria General Hospital in Halifax for 25 years. "But it's not a mature scientific discipline."

Albert Fraser
Retired forensic toxicologist Albert Fraser says hair-based drug and alcohol testing is a 'developing science.' (Submitted by Albert Fraser)

Ontario and New Brunswick have both ordered child protection agencies to stop using hair testing after serious shortcomings were found at the Motherisk lab at The Hospital for Sick Children in Toronto.

Motherisk also conducted tests on as many as 2,300 people in New Brunswick and Nova Scotia, a CBC News investigation has revealed.

Between 1997 and 2005, hundreds of those people produced at least one positive test result indicating the use of drugs or alcohol. The hospital now admits those results may be "inaccurate or unreliable."

After discovering problems at Motherisk, the Ontario government told all social services agencies in the province to stop using hair-strand drug testing "out of an abundance of caution" last April.

A reversal in New Brunswick

New Brunswick followed suit and stopped using the tests, citing concerns about the "overall reliability" of hair testing.

Until then, the province was still ordering hair tests from Dynacare, an Ontario-based lab that says its testing is "robust" and provides "high-quality analytical toxicology service for analysis of drugs-of-abuse in hair."

Meanwhile, Nova Scotia continues to conduct hair testing. Andrea Price, a spokeswoman with Dynacare, confirmed the lab is still performing tests for Nova Scotia. She declined to comment on hair testing moratoriums in other provinces.

Motherisk scandal highlights risk of deferring to experts without questioning credentials

Hundreds of Ontario adoptions on hold amid Motherisk drug-test scandal

However, in a statement to CBC News Monday, Heather Fairbairn, a spokeswoman with Nova Scotia's Department of Community Services signaled there could be a change coming.

"Now that the science behind hair strand testing itself is coming into question, the department is considering the value it may offer to our clients and will be looking at alternative options," Fairbairn said.

"Hair strand analysis was just one among a number of tools the department may employ in child protection cases. However, these results alone would not be the single determining factor in the outcome a case."

Not meeting forensic standards

A review into Motherisk's practices found the lab didn't meet international forensic standards and its leaders had no formal training or experience in forensic toxicology. The lab shut down its hair-testing operations for good last year.

According to Fraser, a forensic lab requires high security because samples may be used in court. Each step of the testing is carefully documented so there's less chance of contamination.

"Almost anything you would think of as being a requirement for forensic identification for a drug in a biological fluid, they didn't follow forensic conventions at all, which is most unfortunate," Fraser said. "It's a tragedy."

But the forensic toxicologist's concerns with hair-based drug testing go beyond Motherisk.

He questions whether the science should be used at all in child protection cases.

'A lot of unanswered questions'

Part of his concern comes from the "colour bias" involved in hair testing.

Because of the different pigments found in hair, Fraser said someone with darker hair may absorb drugs in much higher concentrations than someone with grey or blonde hair.

"It's problematic if one wants to relate the amount of drug that is present to the extent of drug abuse by the individual who had that hair that was being tested," Fraser said.

The concerns are different than with blood or urine testing, which Fraser said has been used "a thousand-fold" more often than hair testing.

He said Nova Scotia should stop all hair testing until it learns more about the science.

"It isn't that hair testing won't have a role," he said. "But you can't go to something that's developing and make that your absolute, because there are still a lot of unanswered questions about the technology."

Still being used in courts

The debate around hair testing is also being waged inside courtrooms.

As recently as February, a judge in Sydney was faced with conflicting drug test results from three different labs, including Motherisk.

Justice Lee Anne MacLeod-Archer set aside all drug testing evidence.

She returned the children to the care of their mother, who insisted she hadn't used drugs in months.

"The evidence is insufficient to prove reliability of those reports for purposes of this proceeding," MacLeod-Archer wrote in her ruling.


Source:
cbc.ca/news/canada/nova-scotia/motherisk-h

 

In reply of
last update
Tuesday, March 8, 2016
legal disclaimer
Audience
Public
Add new
---
Share this Page
Generate PDF file
Generate document Albert Fraser calls hair testing developing science warns against it in child protection cases
Download PDF
Contact
Search Google about
Search bing.com about
Content feed
RSS content feed: Albert Fraser calls hair testing developing science warns against it in child protection cases
Notified by email email notification on replies to this page: Albert Fraser calls hair testing developing science warns against it in child protection cases click here and receive notification of this specific page
Add your Comment Reply add your comments to: Albert Fraser calls hair testing developing science warns against it in child protection cases Reply to in a new window
Create a new page
0 replies
Access Brainsyntax

★★★ ★★★ Become a brainsyntax Member ★★★ ★★★

Access non public pages as Member
Introduce or record new content We are also assisting with content placement, subjects: Family Courts, Family Law Cases, Parental Alienation, Lawyers & Judges, Obstructions of Justice, Police, Courts, spiteful ex's, Hostile aggressive parenting, injustice, malice, obstruction, oppression and many other subjects ... Contact us

★★★ ★★★ Brainsyntax Members, Add new content, build the brainsyntax.com application ★★★ ★★★
Back || Home
X
Latest pages on brainsyntax.com: